embrodski

Aug 292012
 

Of Blood And Honey, by Stina Leicht

Synopsis: A young man (Liam) in 1970s Northern Ireland joins the IRA, discovers he’s a werewolf, and is hunted both by the English Army and Catholic inquisitors. His friend and Catholic priest tries to convince the Church that the Fey and the Fallen are two different races and the Fey are not evil.

Brief Book Review: For the most part, the book is well written. It is very well researched, and the main character grows significantly throughout the story (I found him hard to relate to at first, but that changed as he did). There are a few noticeable problems, particularly the rather lack-luster finale, but on the whole it’s a very good book. Recommended.

Club Review: This is an ideal book for a book club. It has the perfect mix of strengths and weaknesses to really get people talking. The writing and plotting is rather strong most of the time, really drawing in the reader, but with some holes that attentive readers will catch and pick apart in kvetching sessions. More importantly, there are several things several major characters do (or fail to do) that can spark emotional reactions from readers that will likely be brought up, ranging from disbelief to outrage. Numerous aspects of the book can act as productive irritants – The strange moral landscape of the time period chafes a few times. The feeling of living in a divided and occupied country is vivid. The author is fairly even-handed with the political conflict by writing the story from the view of an originally disinterested youngster slowly drawn into political action through various personal forces. The political conflict is very nuanced and grey-shaded, with both sides acting in despicable ways and yet often not seeming unreasonable. The almost comically black-and-white Fallen-vs-Mortals conflict is incongruous enough (and unexplored enough) to make me suspect that future books will be drawing a parallel between the two wars to show that that the Fallen are not pure evil either and extermination is not a viable option.

A Warning – there are several extremely violent scenes. Moreso than most books.

Summary: Lots of grist here. A great mix of good and bad that’ll spark a lot of discussion, with group lamentation about the poor ending. The book itself is very enjoyable, which is a big bonus. Strongly Recommended for book clubs.

Aug 272012
 

I attended a bi-weekly book club, and I’ve noticed something interesting.

Books that are great to read don’t always make astounding books for a book club to read. Patrick Rothfuss’s The Name of the Wind is an amazing book. Utterly enjoyable, well written, and so on. But when we discussed it in our book club the meeting fell short, because there wasn’t that much to say. One can only repeat “This was great! Remember that awesome part where XYZ” so many times.

And books that are kinda crappy can sometimes make for fun discussion (in an MST3K kinda way). We’ve read some fairly bad crap, and the mockery can be very entertaining when done by a witty group with a good sense of humor (which, of course, we are. :) ) Even in otherwise good books it can help to have a few things to kvetch about (seriously, he’s STILL hung up on Denna? Sheez, get over it!)

A lot of books that are moderately enjoyable are absolutely great for book clubs, because there is room for diverging opinions and discussion. What I refer to as “grist”. Something that strikes one person as genius, but another as ham-handed, or pretentious. A fuzzy plot point that a world-class great author would have ironed out, but that leaves things ambiguous and open to interpretation (and thus argument). Some action, or technology, or magic, that one person things is completely unrealistic and/or out-of-character, that another thinks was well-played. Perhaps even politically or ethically controversial assertions. Little bits of irritant that form the focus for a pearl of conversation to coalesce around. These books make for great talks that can go on right up until your venue is closing down and clicking you out the door.

I did a quick google search (admittedly, nothing very indepth), and there doesn’t seem to be any sorts of Reviews of SF/F books for the purpose of book clubs out there. There’s plently of reviews of SF/F books. And there’s even a few Reviews of Books for Book Clubs (which would get the vapors if they read something like genre fiction!). But no reviews of SF/F Books for SF/F Book Clubs.

So I’m going to try my hand at it. Books will be reviewed only after our book club meeting, so I have some empirical evidence rather than just empty speculation. As any review, it is primarily a collection of my opinions, but the hope is that it’ll be opinions others will find useful in some way. First review coming later this week.

Aug 232012
 

In trying to continue my posts on mental plasticity, I’ve found I need to expand on a related subject before I can continue. The following was originally posted at LessWrong.

 

If an AI was asked today how many human individuals populate this planet, it may not return a number the several-billions range. In fact I’d be willing to bet it’d return a number in the tens of thousands, with the caveat that the individuals vary wildly in measure.

I agree with Robin Hanson that if two instances of me exist, and one is terminated, I didn’t die, I simply got smaller.

In 1995 Robert Sapolsky wrote in Ego Boundaries

“My students usually come with ego boundaries like exoskeletons. […] They want their rituals newly minted and shared horizontally within their age group, not vertically over time,” whereas in older societies “needs transcend individual rights to a bounded ego, and people in traditional communities are named and raised as successive incarnations. In such societies, Abraham always lives 900 years–he simply finds a new body to inhabit now and then. ”

Ego boundaries may be more rigid now, but that doesn’t make people more unique. If anything, people have become more like each other. Memes are powerful shapers of mental agents, and as technology allows memes to breed and compete more freely the most viral ones spread through the species.

Acausal trade allows for amazing efficiencies, not merely on a personal level but also via nationalism and religion. People executing strong acausal trading routines will out-compete those who don’t.

Timeless Decision Theory proscribes making decisions as if choosing the outcome for all actors sufficiently like yourself across all worlds. As competition narrows the field of memeplexes to a handful of powerful and virulent ubermemes, and those memeplexes influence the structure and strength of individual’s mental agents in similar ways, people become more like each other. In so doing they are choosing as if a single entity more and more effectively. To an outside observer, there may be very little to differentiate two such humans from each other.

Therefore it may be wrong to think of oneself as a singular person. I am not just me – I am also effectively everyone who is sufficiently like me. It’s been argued that there are only seven stories, and every story can be thought of as an elaboration of one of these. It seems likely there are only a few thousand differentiable people, and everyone is simply one of these with some flare.

If we think of people in these terms, certain behaviors make more sense. Home-schooling is looked down on because institutional schools are about making other people into us. Argument and rhetoric isn’t just a complete waste of your free time, it’s also an attempt to make Meta-Me larger, and Meta-SomeoneElse smaller.

Added Bonus: You no longer have to have many children to exist. You can instead work on enlarging your Meta-Self’s measure.

Aug 212012
 

“Free will” could be exercised in defining the field of battle, not when and how my enemies would attack. Whenever I heard them ask “Would you like that super-sized?” I knew they were really saying “It’s already too late.

 – from This Article by Ta-Nehisi Coates

It’s unfortunate this was sparked by the soda-size restriction, since I think it’s kinda dumb, and I’m interested in the principle rather than that case. I’m of the opinion that all drugs should be legal, so I wouldn’t argue for restrictions on something like soda. But I don’t think “it’s their own choice” makes a good rebuttal because it portrays humans as agents, which is… an exaggeration, at the least. That is the heart of this article. The soda restriction is a very poorly thought out reaction to that human problem. It is, at best, a treatment of one particular and minor symptom. You don’t stop the mafia by making it illegal to say the words “It’d be a shame if something happened to your store.”

When I was originally discussing this with some friends, I was asked –

how do you balance the inability of some people to effectively act as their own agent with allowing drugs to be legal?

Any time a product is sold which is known to be harmful to the user, the seller takes a responsibility to not engage in predatory actions, and to warn the buyers. Predatory action will be prosecuted (and ideally also strongly socially stigmatized), the insanity surrounding the housing/financial crisis of 2008 would have started landing people in jail back in 2004. Certain forms of marketing (colloquially known as “Dark Arts” where I hang out) would be treated the same way, regardless or what the product is.

This would be combined with large-scale education. Every public school would include a Defense Against The Dark Arts class which demonstrates such attacks and attempts to train defense against them, as well as teaching the proper loathing for such violators. And yes, addiction would be treated more like a mental disorder/disease and public health initiatives would include treatment, rather than incarceration. And while I’m at it, everyone gets a pony and a castle and their own flying car.
And for Man’s sake, the government would immediately stop doing this as well. The lottery should be abolished immediately. The government is there to protect us from this shit, not push it on us.

 

Where is the line which delineates predatory action? Who will define that line? I think what a lot of us are saying is that government is not there to protect us from our own stupidity. It’s there to protect us from the tragedy of the commons, and possibly rein in some of the excesses of capitalism. I would also like to add that I love the lottery. There are few better non-cumpulsory sources of revenue for the government.

Where is the line which delineates age of majority? Who will define that line? There are some 14-year-olds out there mature enough to sign contracts, consent to sex, and drink alcohol. And there are some 28-year-olds out there who aren’t. Sometimes we have to draw arbitrary lines, because to not draw any lines is even dumber.

I consider the lottery downright immoral. It’s one thing for a random asshole to set up a casino. It’s another thing entirely for the people who are supposed to defend us to jump in on the action. It’s like the difference between some thug mugging you, and a police officer mugging you. The betrayal makes it more abhorrent. Or, to hearken back to last month, a comedian attacking the defenseless. The lottery is a hostile attack by its nature. It is an exploit no less than any computer virus. The fact that we can spend time/money on anti-virus software to defend ourselves doesn’t make it any less of an assault.I’m not saying the government is there to protect us from our own stupidity per se. But it is there for society to defend itself from outside attacks. The physical attacks are easy to see. But as long as people keep thinking of humans as agents, rather than as biological systems, they’ll have hard time seeing the less violent ways in which humans are hacked. If you believe strongly in individualism I would submit that you’d profit from efforts to defend people from subversion of their volition. I think there’s a big difference between someone being stupid, and a malicious person intentionally targeting others.

 

There have been numerous government agencies set up to defend the public. Police, military, firemen, EPA, FDA, FDIC. There needs to be an agency to fight practitioners of the Dark Arts as well.
Aug 162012
 

Game theory book The Art of Strategy included a great Prisoner’s Dilemma experiment. The experimenters spoiled the game: they told both players that they would be deciding simultaneously, but in fact, they let Player 1 decide first, and then secretly approached Player 2 and told her Player 1’s decision, letting Player 2 consider this information when making her own choice.

The results: If you tell the second player that the first player defected, 3% still cooperate (apparently 3% of people are Jesus). If you tell the second player that the first player cooperated………only 16%  cooperate. When the same researchers in the same lab didn’t tell the second player anything, 37% cooperated.

For those unfamiliar with The Prisoners Dilema, this YouTube video from a British game show will give you an emotional understanding of it in under two minutes (you can keep watching for the awesome twist).

 

The previous was from this Less Wrong post. From the comments:

More surprising [IMO] is the fact that 16% co-operate when they know that it costs them to do so. I have no idea what that 16% were thinking.

In Reply:

This brings me back to the issue of self-identification.

Would you cooperate against yourself?

I realize there are Pansy Parkinson’s out there, I try not to know any. If we achieve an em-future it’ll be important for self-copying entities to have a value set which puts a strong emphasis on cooperating with oneself. The real question (as always) is what counts as me when the simple convention of a continuous physical body is no longer sufficient. As I’ve written before, I adopt a wide enough view that I suspect there may be some people alive right now that count as “close enough”.

Let’s assume I would cooperate against myself. If the only piece of information I have about this other person is they just cooperated, I know that they cooperated with me. I would also cooperate with me. On that axis, they are identical to myself. As I cooperate with myself, I will cooperate with them. (Added bonus: this strengthens the meta-individual)

If I know more about them I can better approximate who they are, and this might change my decision, especially if I expect our groups to come into conflict in the near future. But a simple “if they cooperate, I defect” strategy is self-destructive. A world of everyone running your decision algorithm would result in no player ever cooperating.

Aug 152012
 

Continuing from my last post on working with the human sex drive, describing an Orthodox belief that one should be attracted to one’s mate and no one else.

 

I’d said such selective mental engineering is currently in the realm of magic. It is interesting to consider if we should encourage this once we do have the ability to self-edit at that level. What would be the benefits of such a mental architecture?

The first obvious benefit is that it would free up more time and energy for non-mating pursuits. Apocryphally, Nicola Tesla never pursued women because it would take too much time from his scientific work. I can’t even begin to describe how much more time I had for other work before I met my girlfriend. But redirecting sexual attention to only one partner doesn’t seem to impact this very dramatically, as mating activity seems to follow the familiar 80/20 Rule – 80% of the time is spent on 20% of the work (or in this case, 80% of the time is spent on the primary partner). So if increased productive time is the goal, it’d be far more efficient to remove the sex drive altogether.

The second obvious benefit is in providing a stable single-couple partnership to raise children. I suppose more traditionally-minded people may take this approach when they decide to have children, but I think they’re short-changing themselves. There doesn’t seem to be any reason that an open couple can’t provide and care for children just as well as a closed couple, so there isn’t any inherent reason to strip out the ability to be attracted to others. (In disclosure, I don’t have children of my own. This is based on observation of child-having open couples.)

As the primary function of sex seems to be in creating strong emotion bonds between people, the best (and perhaps only good) reason I can imagine to re-work the sex drive in that way is to form a very strong two-person unit to accomplish a long-term goal that is best executed in two-person teams. The only thing that comes to mind immediately is sniper groups. I see this being used much more frequently in isolated small units that need to cooperate well and trust each other strongly, such as astronauts on long missions or start-up companies. Perhaps the em-teams Robin Hanson postulates. This is not as narrowly focused as the two-person binding originally postulated, but it seems the most practical application of this sort of mental editing.

Aug 142012
 

I stumbled upon an article that described a device you place over your glasses that keeps near objects clear, but blurs your distance vision. Its purpose is to prevent ultra-religious men from seeing a woman and becoming filled with lust.

Lets put aside for a moment the seemingly weird belief that feeling lust is Bad. If one accepts that it is, than this is a clever partial solution that doesn’t intrude on anyone else’s rights. Straight men certainly appreciate the female form, and avoiding it may help with avoiding lust, much like avoiding walking by that delicious-smelling bakery may help with not breaking your diet. Yay Science!

But why did they stop there? Chemical castration has been around for a long while. Like any other tool, it can be used for good or evil. It has been used in the oppression of gays in the past. But I’m glad it is a tool we have available, because sometimes our genes fuck us over. The most horrifying thing I can imagine is being a good person who is stuck with the sexual desires of pedophile. I am grateful I was not dealt that hand, but I thank Man that we’ve created an option for such a person – that if it was me I could have my sex drive removed. Why don’t these men use this tool? If they fear possible permanent damage, couldn’t the ones who’ve fathered all the children they want start a drug regimen? It seems that at least some of them are willing to inconvenience themselves enough to wear blurring glasses – this solution is much more elegant and far less crippling.

An acquaintance who was raised in Orthodox Judaism provided this insight:

they’re supposed to have sex drive…for their wives…when they’re not ‘impure’, that is.

And it dawned on me that I had assumed far too much. They are supposed to be attracted to their wives, but no other women? Do they not realize how humans work?? The characteristics that a man finds attractive in his wife he will  find attractive in other women as well! If he didn’t then he wouldn’t find them attractive in his wife! They don’t even have to be physical characteristics – a man attracted to smart, sarcastic women will find that attractive in any woman.

To remove lust is a problem engineering can help with. But to encourage lust for one person while snuffing it out in all other cases is so far beyond that it’s akin to magic. What kind of deranged memeplex convinces you that you’re a bad person unless you can do magic? No wonder the people harboring them are damaged.

Aug 102012
 

Continuing from the previous post on mental plasticity. Warning – spoilers for Total Recall and major spoilers for Diaspora.

 

Value drift is the term for the incremental changes that occur to people as they go through life that slowly turn them into different persons.

It has been said that value drift is akin to dying. The personality transplant is a common example. Total Recall is a cheesy movie, but it is fun, and it serves as a fine example. Quaid hates Hauser, and works against his interests. They are very much two different people who happened to both inhabit the same body at different times. What does it matter if the personality change happens over a period of minutes, or a period of decades? Either way the first individual is effectively dead, and has been replaced by the second. Why should I strive for immortality if I am destined to fade away anyway, if my labor is for the benefit of some individual I may hate? Thus the argument for preservation of values.

I disagree. Life is a process of change, it cannot be static. A static body is a dead body, and a static mind is a barren mind. In Greg Egan’s “Diaspora”  the protagonists search for a civilization of ancient trans-dimensional spacefarers. They eventually find their legacy – a structure of such immensity it’s difficult to describe*. In a single dimension it is the size of a planet, but it spans uncountable dimensions, a total mass so great it would collapse into a super-massive black hole should all that matter be gathered in a single dimension. It is composed of memory diamond, and is hypothesized to store the complete mental run states of every person in the civilization across their entire existence. Everything everyone has ever thought in every second, preserved eternally in a solid state. And they even shaped it to physically resemble a typical member of their species.

That is true static perfection. To win against value drift one needs only to create such a statue of themselves, preserving their entire existence across time in an indestructible physical form. Never will they change.

One may argue that this is not life, this does not accurately capture their values, because one thing they value is to interact with reality. I’ll pick this up and continue with it in the next post in this series.

 

* This is from memory, I don’t have the book in front of me, so my details may be off.

Aug 072012
 

Recently at my work we had an intern. I was tasked with giving her some of my work to keep her busy. In theory, this would reduce my workload as well, since she was doing it. In practice, I had no motivation to make sure she was doing things well. In a month she’ll be gone, and I’ll be doing this myself again, so it doesn’t matter if she does a great job or a crap one, as long as it isn’t too screwed up for me to recover afterward. So I gave her a quick crash course, she spent an hour “being busy”, and afterwards I threw away all her work and redid it the way it should be.

Because it was easier than training her fully, and it doesn’t matter anyway.

I suspect a lot of office work follows this pattern. People do work they don’t need to do simply because it’s easier for a supervisor to let them do it, and it doesn’t matter because there is plenty of surplus labor available at the office. When one of my co-workers moved away a couple months ago she trained me in taking over a few of her duties. After she left the Director above both of us told me to simply not do about 70% of that. It wasn’t used for anything.

This is how we have “jobless recoveries”. When there is a recession and a corporation doesn’t have excess income to pass around they can drop 20% of their work force and not lose any productivity, because 20% of the work was useless anyway. There is no need to rehire those employees after the recovery.

On the one hand, this is pretty horrifying to my capitalistic side. This is NOT how capitalism is supposed to work dammit! It’s supposed to be lean and mean, where waste is rewarded with bankruptcy! On the other hand, it’s kinda comforting for my socialistic side. These corporations are miniature welfare states, helping the public by providing unnecessary jobs for the unemployed out of their excess profits. They only shed these welfare jobs when forced to by a tightening market. Yes – they’re doing so unwittingly, and only because of human laziness. And it is ultimately inefficient and detrimental to economic growth. But it’s still kinda cute.

Aug 032012
 

A common pro-death argument is that without the older generations dying off, humanity was stagnate and social progress will end. This is often supported with Planck’s quote that “An important scientific innovation rarely makes its way by gradually winning over and converting its opponents. What does happen is that its opponents gradually die out, and that the growing generation is familiarized with the ideas from the beginning.”

My first response is that killing off an entire generation is the worst possible way to solve these problems. I then point out that their claims are false, scientists often change their minds when presented with compelling evidence, and people can train themselves to update their beliefs.

Robin Hanson recently pointed out a more realistic pitfall of an unbounded lifespan – it is far less practical to re-engineer a system that’s been specialized for one environment to fit into a different environment than to just take a simple non-specialized system and specialize it to the new environment.

In general, the more different is the new environment from the old, the better it is to start over. Old  systems tend to be rigid, which makes them fragile, in that they break if you bend them too far.

This suggests that designed systems tend to get irreversibly fragile as they adapt to specific environments. When context changes greatly, it is usually easier to build new systems from “scratch,” than to un-adapt systems designed for other contexts.

[…] our minds seem designed to adapt to the environment in which we grow up, via youthful plasticity transitioning to elderly rigidity. For example, we are great at learning languages when young, and terrible when old. We are similarly receptive when young to new ways to categorize and conceive of things, but once we have often used particular ways, we find it harder to understand and use alternatives.

I don’t think this is an insurmountable problem. In the biological state it is likely we will develop a drug akin to those described in Bruce Sterling’s “Schismatrix” that reverts the mind to a more adolescent state and makes the brain more malleable. In an emulated state it can’t be too difficult to modify our programming to enable similar effects.

What I’m more concerned about is the problem of self-identity. I feel many of my rationalist brethern are too concerned with value-drift. I fear they may refuse to change in a belief that such change, accumulating slowly over many decades, will lead to the eventual extinction and replacement of their current self with someone new. This may be a valid fear, but life itself is a process of change. To create a perfectly static image of oneself which cannot be altered is as good as death, one might as well simply make a statue of himself and call that immortality (as explored in Egan’s “Diaspora”).

On the other hand, too rapid a change is also terrifying. What good is continuing “your” life when the you of a few weeks ago cannot recognize or empathize with the you that currently exists? Would the current you sacrifice her life for the future you to come into existence?

I plan to explore this in a series of blog posts over the next few weeks. Until then, here’s a fictional example of a far too rapid personality change, the kind we want to avoid.