embrodski

Jul 312012
 

It sucks being retarded.

That should go without saying, and yet I feel incredibly nervous saying it.

Last week at our book club we read the Hugo-nominated short stories, which included “Movement”. It asks the question – if we can cure a certain type of mental handicap, should we do so?

I feel the answer is very obvious. I’m saddened that many people disagree. In this case, one of the attendees was a teacher of special-needs children, and made an impassioned speech about how great these children are. I have no doubt they are great children. I recognize that sometimes terrible things happen and we, as a society, refuse to be heartless bastards and leave the helpless to die. This is part of what makes us great! We work together and help the vulnerable.

But this is sci-fi, it asks “what if”. And this story asks if (IF!!) we should cure such people, given that a partial cure was available. The character in the story (Hannah) cannot support herself. She lives entirely on the charity of others. If not for them, she would likely soon die of starvation, exposure, or predation. Her desire to continue living this lifestyle cannot be given priority over those of her care-givers. She is incompetent to make such a decision. It is obvious what the best course of action is, and yet the story attempts to portray this in a negative light. To live as an infant is not a beautiful thing – it is a tragic waste of a life.

There is too much exultation of that damaged state. Praise that these are the happiest children, and bring a great deal of joy to their parents. In our book club, the teacher claimed that no parent of any of her kids would want for their child to be cured if such a thing was possible. It is eerily similar to the way most people praise death, and those who embrace it. There seem to be a certain percentage of the population that simply can’t say that some things are unfortunate but must be dealt with while we attempt to solve them, realizing that many lives will be wasted before a solution is found. I think this is part of the reason that anti-aging research gets so little attention. Too much veneration of the unavoidable bad.

No one would intentionally make their child retarded. So why claim that these are such wonderful things? If you wouldn’t intentionally cripple someone to gain these benefits, why would you prevent someone from being cured?

This veneration has practical consequences now, before a cure is even on the horizon. In this otherwise excellent post Melissa states:

when a special needs person becomes an adult in Canada, they are eligible for a personal care assistant covered by the government. We saw far more developmentally or physically disabled persons out and about in Canada, than I ever see here in the USA. They would be getting their groceries at the store, doing their business at the bank, and even working job, all with their personal care assistant alongside them, encouraging them and helping them when they needed it. When my sister came up to visit, she even commented on how visible special needs people were when the lady smiling and waving while clearing tables at the Taco Bell with her caregiver clearly had Downs Syndrome.

This seems to me to be clearly excessive. I haven’t read about this practice, but if this is true, aren’t there more efficient ways to deal with the mentally handicapped than personal assistants? How much is society investing into that Taco Bell job? How many people are being diverted from more productive careers into this care-giving role? Melissa speaks positively about this program, and that it reduces abortion by encouraging mothers with Down’s Syndrome fetuses to carry to term. That is horrible! Stopping that sort of pregnancy is part of why we have prenatal testing in the first place! For it not to be taken advantage of is a travesty!

This celebration of tragedy is pervasive. A coworker once remarked that Schindler’s List reaffirmed his belief in a god. To emphasize: a story about the most publicized and reviled genocide in recent history makes him feel there is a benevolent father watching over us. The worship of a few good points in an unmitigated disaster blows my mind.

Jul 312012
 

Presenting the Deadline FAQ. All the questions about Mira Grant’s Deadline that you wish someone had asked before you picked up this book.

 

Q: Will there be spoilers?

A: SOOOOOOO many spoilers!

 

Q: This seems to be a direct rip-off of the internet-famous Transformers 2 FAQ. Why is that?

A: This book has the plotting and attention to detail of a Michael Bay movie, so I thought it’d be the most appropriate format.

 

Q: Ooooooh burn! But I assume that means we get lots of spectacular action scenes to make up for it!

A: It’s unfortunate you would assume that. One would think a book about zombies would have some excitement or terror in it at some point. Or maybe even a finale that happens to the protagonists. Instead, the awesome ZOMG-EPIC!! finale – a second Rising, a re-Apocalypse – happens entirely off-screen. Or rather, literally on a TV screen. Rather than involving the characters in any way, they just watch a couple news reports on CNN. That is the action-packed grand finale. It’s not quite as bad as listening to a radio report while stuck in traffic, but it’s close.

 

Q: Hold on, we’re getting ahead of ourselves – third answer and we’re already at the end of the book? Back up. This is a sequel so catch us up – at the beginning, what has Shaun been doing since the previous book?

A: Well it’s been about a year since Feed ended and his sister was murdered. Since that time Shaun’s been sitting around and thinking that he really ought to go and find out who was responsible for that. Unfortunately no convenient plot devices have dropped into his lap, so he hasn’t actually done anything.

 

Q: Why not? He’s a journalist! Shouldn’t he be out investigative-reportering all over this piece? Maybe setting down a lot of ground work off-screen so that the story can begin right as a crucial detail falls into place and the excitement starts?

A: He probably SHOULD, yes. But it seems Mira Grant doesn’t understand what journalist do. That’s a common theme in the book. Shaun and his team risk their lives to get crucial information that the public should know. Information along the lines of “the people you thought were protecting you are actually murdering US citizens, breeding a more deadly virus, and could have wiped out zombie-ism decades ago”. Forget Watergate, this is a 9/11 Truther’s wet dream. And Shaun makes sure this information is encrypted, hidden away, and not in any way released. Those responsible are trying to silence him, and the best way to stay on their hit-list is to make sure the truth dies with him!

 

Q: That’s staggeringly stupid. Why would he do that?

A: The book actually does a good job establishing that Shaun isn’t very bright. His main mode of interaction with other people is threats of beating/murder, and displays of physical violence. At one point he throws an incendiary grenade inside a building that HE IS IN. One that he believes is sealed and he has no way of getting out of. And that’s not even the dumbest thing he does.

 

Q: Woah. So… how does he uncover this vast conspiracy then?

A: A plot device falls in his lap. Technically, it knocks on his front door. To be fair, it is explained later as a trap by the villain to kill Shaun.

 

Q: Why would the villain bother to kill Shaun? I thought he was sitting around doing nothing and being a complete non-threat?

A: It’s because the villain is eeeeeeeviiiillllll. Seriously, he’s a moustache-twirler. Rather than save the world and cure the zombie plague he (and his cabal) are killing people who develop immunities and making stronger, better zombie viruses because that is Evilly Evil. It’s interesting, Mira apparently realized her last villain was an over-the-top caricature, and so explains that this was intentional so that everyone would focus on the Fake Evil Bad Guy and be distracted from the Real Guild of Calamitous Intent. However this is explained by a guy who is even MORE of a villain caricature. This information is literally revealed by the villain while he is Monologuing, as he is holding a pretty girl hostage. It’s hard to get any more clichéd.

 

Q: Hah!! I suppose they could have left the protagonists alone in an easily escapable room and expected an overly-elaborate death-trap to do them in, amirite? :)

A: …

 

Q: Oh you have GOT to be kidding me!?

A: Let’s just move on.

 

Q: So there have got to be some good parts to this book, right?

A: Actually yes, there are. This seems to be more of a relationship book, and the relationship in it is very strong. The whole dynamic of Shaun being crazy and speaking to his dead sister’s voice in his head works very well. His longing and pain is palpable and very touching. There are some truly great scenes of him pouring his heart out to her. The “Yup, they were sleeping together” reveal is exceptionally well done –

 

Q: I KNEW IT!!!

A: That’s not a question. But yes, all suspicions are confirmed, and it works very well. The scene when it’s revealed that Shaun didn’t need to kill her, she probably would have gotten better from the zombification, was also incredibly good. And some of the details – like him picking up her Coke-drinking habit after she dies even though he hates Coke – are also nice touches.

 

Q: Well why are you focusing on the bad stuff then?

A: Because there is so much bad stuff in between the few good scenes. This book is 600 pages, and should have been maybe 200. You can skim the majority of it, skipping whole paragraphs and sometimes whole pages, because the informational content of any given paragraph is so low. You know the first fifteen minutes of Manos: The Hands of Fate?

 

Q: You mean the movie often called one of the worst movies ever made? The first fifteen minutes of which consist of nothing but a car driving through a field while absolutely nothing happens?

A: That’s the one. A lot of the book is like that. Have you ever wanted to read about a loooooooooong road trip, through the middle of an abandoned country? Where uneventful rest-stops are described in detail? You can hear about every exciting stop for gas, and get a blow-by-blow description of the GPS unit re-routing our heroes along a slightly different path!

 

Q: But what would they eat on such a trip? What would they wear into the convenience store?

A: Fret not! You can read all about the outfits they change into as they made bathroom breaks. Thrill to the descriptions of meals of potato chips, donuts with bad plasticy frosting, seventeen bags of M&Ms, knock-off Everclear, and bottles and bottles of Coke!

 

Q: Couldn’t this narrative be spiced up with some automated blood tests?

A: Indeed! You will get to read about hundreds of blood tests! Every few pages will be another description of more blood tests, usually several at once! On multiple occasions we go directly from one blood test to ANOTHER blood test! How many times will the lights flash red/green? Only one way to find out!

 

Q: Actually, getting serious again – what do you mean potato chips, M&Ms, and Coke? Isn’t this a post-zombie-apocalypse novel?

A: Yeah, it’s weird. Despite the descriptions of abandoned rural areas and empty fields, there’s no food shortages. Cell phones are still cheaply available and there’s plenty of gasoline – it seems there hasn’t been any significant international trade disruption. It’s like the world didn’t even notice that a signification fraction of it was killed not that long ago. I suppose that’s not impossible a couple decades after the fact, Europe was well on the road to recovery a couple decades after WW2, but that took lots of support from the US, and they weren’t simultaneously flooded with the refugees of all of India. Much of the book didn’t seem well thought out or researched.

 

Q: I think you’re being a little too critical. It’s a zombie book, why go all deep-Stross on it?

A: OK, but even a lot of the surface-level plotting was simply nonsensical. A lot of the non-roadtrip action is breaking into CDC offices. Let’s play a game. You want to get into the guarded compound of the most powerful organization in the world. Go.

 

Q: Um… how would I do that?

A: Unspecificed! Let’s simply walk up to a front/side door and see what happens.

 

Q: Why am I doing this again?

A: We don’t know! Could be interesting. Maybe poke some extremely powerful people with sticks to see what happens. BTW – congrats, you made it into the world’s most powerful and evil HQ without a hitch.

 

Q: I did? But, aren’t these guys extremely powerful and scary? They sound kinda incompetent….

A: Yeah, it’s a bit hard to take them seriously. No matter how many times the narrator says “Big, Scary, Evil!  World-spanning Bad-ass Organization of Doom! Be Afraid!” it simply doesn’t make an impact when the actions we see from them are all weak, stupid, incompetent bumbling. It doesn’t evoke a lot of tension when you realize the villains are even dumber than the “let’s ride my motorcycle through a countryside infested with zombies instead of riding inside the armored van just a few yards ahead of me” hero.

 

Q: I’m not even going to dignify that with a comment. OK, so now that we made it inside without any opposition, what should we do?

A: Let’s just walk in and see what we can see. Hey, their entire plans for world domination via their hand-made super-zombie-virus are written out on this chalkboard? How handy!

 

Q: ARGH! My poor abused suspension of disbelief! It hurts!! But now how do I get out again?

A: You just happen to know about a “super-secret” passageway that comes standard in all CDC buildings and is never locked or guarded!

 

Q: I… what… NO! Screw this – I quit.

A: K, bye. Oh, BTW, George is resurrected at the end.

 

Q: WHAT!?!?!?!!?

A: Yeah, I know. :/

 

Bonus Round!

Q: OK, so despite my better judgement I went ahead and read this book. Can I ask a few follow-up questions?

A: Fire away.

 

Q: When Shaun says that the dog sniffed his crotch in the universal greeting of all dogs – how does he know that? There hasn’t been a dog big enough to reach his crotch alive in his entire lifetime.

A: Genetic memory…?

 

Q: And why the hell do they keep going back to Maggie’s place over and over? There’s absolutely no way the CDC hasn’t tracked them to it by now, it should’ve had a bomb dropped on it halfway through the book. And it completely removes any sense of danger or fear in the novel to have an impenetrable fortress you can fall back to at any time, rather than hiding in the ruins and praying you aren’t found. It makes the world-spanning extremely-powerful government agency feel like a kitten instead of an army of Terminators. Seriously, Maggie’s place was several times more secure than the CDC facilities. A rich kid’s mansion should not have security that makes the shadowy overlords of the country look feeble in comparison. The building housing the Ultimate Plans of Virus Purification was a tree-fort compared to Maggie’s place!

A: Think of the book as a video game (the author does, and specifically mentioned it a few times). After every level there’s a safe zone during which you can save your game and take as long as you need to rest, go to the bathroom, or finish your homework before you get back to it.

 

Q: Love that realism. Why did Dave have to die? I get that he had to hold down a button to keep a gate open, but that seems kinda dumb and contrived.

A: Motivation for the other characters, maybe? Since exposing the truth obviously isn’t a priority, and Shaun’s already been doing nothing about exacting revenge for his sister.

 

Q: Speaking of death – does his death really matter anymore? This is a world with resurrection tech now! We can bring back Buffy, Dave, Kelly, everyone! Huzzah!

A: Yup, death seems to be solved. Kinda makes that absolutely INCREDIBLE death-scene at the end of Feed pointless now, eh? And while it was certainly touching to see Shaun struggling with loneliness and survivor’s guilt, the entire first 98% of the book is now also less meaningful. It’s like a book about a family dealing with cancer in which on the last page it’s revealed that – good news! You don’t actually have cancer after all! The impact is muted. And it really changes the entire nature of the setting. This is no longer a zombie horror, it’s a post-mortality transhumanism story. Except I strongly suspect that the third book will continue pretending to be a zombie horror.

 

Q: Doesn’t solving death make the CDC the heroes of all humanity?

A: Well, I suppose it depends on just how much evil they did to get there. It’d certainly count as mitigating circumstances though. But I suspect they’ll somehow suppress it and use it only for their nefarious purposes.

 

Q: Which they would do… why, exactly?

A: Same reason they’re perfecting the zombie virus and murdering tons of civilians – they’re love being eeeeeeviiiiiilll!

 

Q: Of course. Why did I even ask?

A: The FAQ format demands it.

 

Jul 272012
 

The Mayor of Boston wrote a letter to Chik-Fil-A stating “There’s no place for discrimination on Boston’s Freedom Trail and no place for your company alongside it.” Full Size Image Here.

I thought about this myself a bit. I’m an atheist, and it’s actually still very common for political officials to say things like “we don’t want any stinking atheist businesses in this town” or something similar. It’s been a couple decades now, but I recall when Bush Sr said he didn’t think atheists should be considered American citizens.

I still think mayor Menino did a good thing. For exactly the same reason I think Bush Sr did a bad thing. Bush perpetuated bigotry. Menino is fighting against it. Fighting against bigotry is a GOOD THING. Anyone who does so gets my support. Anyone who attacks someone who is fighting against bigotry gets only my contempt (or, at the least, my disapproval, if that person is a well-meaning but confused friend).

Is the government suddenly not allowed to stop bad things for some reason?

Free speech isn’t being attacked. He isn’t putting anyone in jail, giving any fines, or refusing any permits, no rights have been violated. He’s primarily rallying the power of public opinion. Which is a GOOD use of power in the pursuit of a GOOD goal. Major kudos to him.

 

Apparently at first he did say he’d use his power to stop Chik-Fil-A from receiving permits.  I’m glad he backed away from that route, as that would be abuse and illegal. His public letter is fine, and awesome.

Jul 202012
 

Note: I wrote this before Death Is Bad was up. I originally posted it to my other site, HPMoR:The Podcast. I’ve moved it here, but I’ve left the original post uneditted.


 

I was woken up this morning by my phone ringing. I ignored the first call, but when it was followed by another call immediately I assumed something was urgently wrong. It was my brother, stationed in New York, calling to ask if I’d “done anything dumb” like go see the Batman midnight premiere. After a “What? No…?” he said that was good and he had to call our other brother.

For a second I considered going back to bed. But when that’s your wake up call you know something bad has happened at a Denver Batman premiere. And since it’s a Batman premiere, you immediately think a crazy man shot, exploded, or otherwise murderized a movie theater.


I think everyone I know is safe. At the very least, everyone I care about deeply is safe.

Some small part of me can almost empathize with the shooter. That’s the shit part of all this, and that’s why I need to vent.

A truly great work of fiction changes the way you see the world. The Dark Knight (2nd movie) was truly great. That’s why there were rumors after Heath Ledger’s passing that his acting as the Joker was partly responsible for his death. Take something that’ll twist your view of humanity and reality for two hours, make yourself the focal point of that twisting, and live it for months. How could someone not be changed by that? All folk psychology. Actually shooting a movie is nothing like living inside it. As Jack Nicholson said, to suggest his death was caused by a role he played is insulting to actors everywhere, and to the memory of Ledger in particular.

But the audience, we can live in a movie for two hours. If someone gets really wrapped up in it, he can live in that world for days, or months. He already has to be a little bit crazy, of course, a bit detached. And that’s why we can relate to the crazy-fuck shooter. We’re all a little bit crazy nowadays, we all live in a world that’s only half real, the other half a constructed façade we make for ourselves and agree to respect. So we imagine what it must be like, to be more than just a bit crazy, to be full-on insane and tear through that façade and be unable to understand why everyone else is still bound by it. There is nothing there!

Now and then, there is a slip. What if someone really WAS the Joker? What if someone brought that chaos into the real world, and showed people what a joke we all live inside of? It wouldn’t take much, would it? Go to a movie theater and bring them into the movie. Make life surreal, make it like the altered reality I’ve been half-living all these months. It shouldn’t be that hard, to make life a movie.


The real question is – Joker outfit, or Bane outfit? At first glance it should be the Joker outfit. After all, this is a Joker emulation. It is exactly the sort of thing he would do. And no one’s seen Bane yet, this may not be Bane’s style. It probably isn’t, actually, he seems more focused than the Joker. So… Joker. But – Joker is sooo two years ago. Bane is now. Bane is what’s happening. When bringing the movies to life you have to bring the current movie that everyone cares about to life. Not the last installment. How sad. Poor little crazy man, living in the past, all hung up on a fad that’s passed. No, it has to be new, it has to be hip. As every revolutionary knows, style is important. So – Bane it is. Black leather and gas mask. Done.

Who knows but Joker would’ve done the same?


Obviously this is horrific, and only an actual insane person would do this. The brother who called me just got back from a year-long tour in Afghanistan. I can’t imagine him going to a midnight showing, out for some fun with his friends in a supposedly safe place, able to finally be at ease… and then have this madman break in and start shooting. Maybe shoot my brother, leave him crippled, or dead. Surviving a year at war only to be killed in a movie theater.

Actually I can imagine it, which is worse. What I can’t imagine is my reaction.

I hate that I can relate. When one steps back for just one second and considers what’s actually happening… the lives destroyed, the way the real world is torn asunder. How could I have empathized even for one minute? But then you step forward again and there it is. It’s intoxicating while you’re in it. Intoxicating is actually a good analogy, it’s just as distorting and harmful. It’s the same way deep religion submerses you in a fantastic altered reality.


I had an almost identical reaction to the Columbine shooting. Although this really can’t compare. This was just waking up and hearing the news. Columbine played out live in front of me, stretching out over hours. I chain-smoked while I watched, and wrote, although I don’t have those notes anymore. I’m sure they were similar. I’m not sure why I chain-smoked through it. I suppose it felt appropriate to have the air swimming with murky whorls of grey, dancing in the sunbeams. One always tries to shape their environment to reflect their mental state, no?


Why is the President commenting on this? Are we all really that close to the line of insanity? Is that why this is such a big story right now? Kids are shot every day in the inner cities, no one comments on that. Maybe it’s just because this is not part of the plan.


I don’t know if my mental state actually reflects what these mad fucks are feeling. Maybe I’m projecting far too much. I think I can say one thing with some confidence though. When they actually went through with these acts, the reality of what happened was nothing at all like how they imagined it would be.

Jul 152012
 

Presumably you’ve heard all about Daniel Tosh’s recent hilarious take on rape. A woman in the audience yelled out that rape jokes aren’t funny and…

From Cookies For Breakfast:

After I called out to him, Tosh paused for a moment. Then, he says, “Wouldn’t it be funny if that girl got raped by like, 5 guys right now? Like right now? What if a bunch of guys just raped her…” and I, completely stunned and finding it hard to process what was happening but knowing i needed to get out of there, immediately nudged my friend, who was also completely stunned, and we high-tailed it out of there. It was humiliating, of course, especially as the audience guffawed in response to Tosh, their eyes following us as we made our way out of there. I didn’t hear the rest of what he said about me.

A good comedian can joke about anything. But the thing is,  you have to be an actual good comedian. Comedian is a noble profession. The comedian can/should use his power to challenge the powerful and the oppressor, and/or help the powerless get through another shitty day. The Jester mocks the king. A comedian who abuses his power is like a police officer who abuses his. They’re entrusted with the power to help the powerless, and it’s a gross violation when they turn around and use that power to prey on the weak.

Done right, you have Jeff Foxworthy helping his fellow rednecks laugh at their plight in life and keep on plugging. Done wrong, you’re Michael Richards. Or Tosh.